Photo credit: Shutter Studios- Left to Right: Scott Maudsley, Sarah Machin Gale, Mayson Sonntag and Erin MacKinnon
There’s something comforting about a story you know is going to leave you smiling.
That’s exactly how I felt watching Sugar Road, Kristen Da Silva’s romantic comedy now playing at Port Stanley Festival Theatre. I was already familiar with Da Silva’s work going into the production, but this was my first time seeing the show. It didn’t take long to understand why it has become a favourite for audiences looking for a feel-good experience at the theatre.
The production features Erin MacKinnon as Hannah alongside Mayson Sonntag as Jesse, with Sarah Machin Gale portraying Caroline and Scott Maudsley as Ray.
Set against the backdrop of a small-town country fair, the story follows two former sweethearts, Jesse, the now-famous country music heartthrob and Hannah, the small-town girl, who unexpectedly cross paths years after sharing a memorable night together.
It’s a familiar premise, but one that’s brought to life with plenty of heart, humour and just the right amount of country music. It sort of reminded me of a Hallmark movie.
The story embraces the warmth, optimism and small-town charm that fans of the genre have come to expect, without feeling overly predictable. Instead, it creates an easygoing atmosphere that allows audiences to simply sit back and enjoy the ride.
One of the production’s biggest strengths is its design. Once again, set designer Eric Bunnell proves why his work continues to stand out at Port Stanley Festival Theatre. The rustic feel, complete with weathered structures and charming fairground details, immediately transports audiences into Sugar Road.
I also appreciated one of the show’s more subtle creative choices. Rather than relying on elaborate lighting effects or lengthy transitions to distinguish present-day scenes from memories, the production uses a simple change in Hannah’s hairstyle—from hair up to hair down—to signal the shift. It’s a small detail, but an effective one that keeps the story moving naturally.
While romance is at the heart of Sugar Road, it’s the combination of humour, music and genuine warmth that makes the production so enjoyable. It doesn’t try to reinvent the romantic comedy. Instead, it leans into everything audiences love about the genre.
If you’re looking for an afternoon or evening filled with laughs, nostalgia and a story that leaves you feeling good on the drive home, Sugar Road is well worth the trip to Port Stanley. It runs through July 25th, with tickets available at PSFT.ca.
Written by: Kennedy Freeman
Please note that the views expressed in this piece are based on my own experience and opinion.
